Tendance Coatesy

Left Socialist Blog

Stop pretending that you can’t do anything to save Syrians.

with 3 comments

“Hours into second attempt at implementing Russian truce, government shelling intensifies in towns near front lines.” Al Jazeera.

Lois Proyect has just published this from Pulse.

It should have the widest circulation.

“This open letter was first published at the New York Review of Books.”

The World Must Act Now on Syria

Stop pretending that you can’t do anything to save Syrians

The UN says it has run out of words on Syria, but we, the undersigned, still have some for the governments, parliamentarians, electorates and opinion leaders of the powers on whom the international legal order has hitherto depended.

The world is a bystander to the carnage that has ravaged the lives of Syrians. All has happened in full view of a global audience that sees everything but refuses to act.

Through Russian obstruction and western irresolution, the UN Security Council has failed to protect Syrians. To the extent that it has been able to pass resolutions, they have proved ineffectual. All they have done is provide a fig leaf to an institution that appears moribund. Perhaps conscious of the stain this might leave on its legacy, the UN has even stopped counting Syria’s dead. After seven years, these nations appear united only in their apathy.

It will be redundant to list the nature and magnitude of all the crimes that the Assad regime has committed against Syrians, aided by local and foreign militias, by Iranian strategic and financial aid, by Russian airpower and mercenaries—and by international indifference. The world that watched and averted its eyes is its passive enabler.

Syrians were shot and killed in broad daylight for protesting injustice. They were imprisoned, tortured and executed. They were bombed and shelled. They were besieged, raped and humiliated. They were gassed. They were displaced and dispossessed.

Those with the power to act have been generous with expressions of sympathy but have offered nothing beyond the wish that this war on civilians—which they grotesquely call a “civil war”—would end. They call on “all parties” to show restraint, even though one side alone has a virtual monopoly on violence; they encourage all parties to negotiate, even though the opposition is entirely without leverage. They say there is “no military solution” though the regime has given no indication that it believes in a solution of any other kind.  Meanwhile, pleas from aid agencies and endangered Syrians fall on deaf ears.

Refugees—the only Syrians to have received some assistance—have seen their plight depoliticized, isolated from the terror that forced them to flee.

Today, as Idlib and Afrin burn, the inevitable is unfolding in Ghouta, the huge open air concentration camp about to enter its fifth year under siege. What happens next is predictable because the same formula has been applied repeatedly over the past seven years. After holding a civilian population hostage, blocking food, medicine and aid of any kind, the regime bombs the area relentlessly, in particular its medical facilities, until it capitulates. Those that survive are then forced from their homes that are then expropriated for demographic engineering with the aim of creating politically homogenous geographies.

While there are no longer any illusions about the role of the Security Council, every member state has nevertheless adopted and pledged to uphold the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) doctrine under the UN’s Office on Genocide Prevention. The destruction of Syria was preventable, and can now only be ended by the elected and appointed members of democratic bodies if they fulfill their obligations under R2P to protect Syria’s endangered population from war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and what UN war crimes investigators have themselves labeled the “crime of extermination”.

For the agony of the people of Syria to come to an end, it must be forcibly stopped. The perpetrators of these colossal crimes against humanity must be halted once and for all. There are myriad geopolitical reasons why this is an imperative, but none as immediate and important as the sanctity of life and the exercise of free will. Inaction would reduce these principles to the status of platitudes devoid of all meaning. To their misfortune, Syrians dared to believe in these principles; they dared to believe that while their struggle for dignity was theirs alone, they wouldn’t be abandoned to such a fate in the 21st century.

Today, appealing once more to the ethics and the codes of moral conduct on which democracy and international law are built, we ask you to act now to stop the Syrian genocide: demand an immediate ceasefire, an immediate lifting of all sieges, immediate access for relief aid agencies, release of political detainees, and immediate protection for all Syrian lives.

Affiliations for identification purposes only

  • Yassin Al-Haj Saleh, writer, Berlin
  • Robin Yassin-Kassab, writer, Scotland
  • Rime Allaf, Writer
  • Leila Al Shami, Syrian writer and human rights activist, UK
  • Mohammad Al Attar, Syrian Playwright, Berlin
  • Michel Kilo, Syrian writer and Politician, Paris
  • Moncef Marzouki, Former President of Tunisia
  • Burhan Ghalioun, Academician and Thinker, Paris
  • Karam Nachar, Syrian Writer and Academic, Istanbul
  • Mohammad Ali Atassi, Journalist and Filmmaker, Beirut
  • Ossama Mohammed, Filmmaker, Paris
  • Yasmin Fedda, Filmmaker, UK
  • Fadel Abdul Ghany, Chairperson of the Syrian Network for Human Rights
  • Ebrahim Alyousef, President of Human Rights Association in Syria, Germany
  • Nisrin Al Zahre, École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales, Paris
  • Nadia Aissaoui, Sociologist, Paris
  • Leila Nachawati Rego, Writer, Spain
  • Hala Mohammad, Syrian Poet, Paris
  • Afra Jalabi, Syrian Writer, Canada
  • Mohja Kahf, Syrian writer
  • Yasser Munif, Emerson College
  • Mohammed Hanif, Writer and Journalist, Polish Academy of Sciences
  • Samih Choukaer, Syrian Musician, Paris
  • Professor, Martti Koskenniemi, University of Helsink
  • Professor, Martti Koskenniemi, University of Helsinki
  • Professor Gilbert Achcar, SOAS

Further list on site.

For reasons to back the call see Shiraz Socialist,  The bombing has not stopped: Ghouta after the ‘ceasefire’.

Advertisements

Written by Andrew Coates

February 28, 2018 at 12:51 pm

3 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. From: Idrees Ahmad
    Date: Tue, Feb 27, 2018 at 12:48 PM
    Subject: [Critical-Syria] East Ghouta: Are we blind to Syria’s latest tragedy?
    To: Critical Syria

    London friends, Leila and I will be speaking at the Frontline Club on the 13th of March. If you are around, it would be good to see you.
    https://www.frontlineclub.com/east-ghouta-are-we-blind-to-syrias-latest-tragedy/

    Dr. Muhammad Idrees Ahmad
    Lecturer in Digital Journalism
    University of Stirling

    Jim Denham

    February 28, 2018 at 3:17 pm

  2. […] Also Ipswich Barmy Bolshevik Blogger, Comrade Coates has written an article titled “Stop pretending that you can’t do anything to save Syrians” here. […]

  3. Proyect is an unrepentant Marxist, at least according to himself, and it shows. What is this letter and to who is it addressed? Who is supposed to stop pretending? Presumably ourselves, the West which in the contorted and distorted thinking of Marxists is responsible for everything bad in the world that has ever happened. The whole things is snowflake virtue signalling, nothing else.

    The only way to stop what is happening is to begin an sustained bombing campaign of Assad’s troops and assets and as they are gradually rolled back and destroyed to put European and US boots on the ground to fill the vacuum until a democratically elected government can run the country. The last begs the question what is the country because number of groups most prominently the Kurds want independence.

    Only western military intervention will stop the fighting and the international left won’t have that because it’s imperialism, and it’s all about oil, and it’s meant to draw Russia into a regional war to get rid of Putin, and it’s this and it’s that. Silly article, nothing to see, move on.

    Dave Roberts

    March 1, 2018 at 7:55 am


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: