Tendance Coatesy

Left Socialist Blog

Posts Tagged ‘Culture

Tunisian State Detains Rappers for Being Rude about the Police.

with 2 comments

Not to Islamists’ Taste.

More repression by Tunisian Islamist Government.

Alakhabar reports.

Tunisian authorities have detained two people and charged them with insulting security forces in a rap video uploaded to the Internet, the interior ministry said on Tuesday.

“The rap video posted on YouTube called ‘Boulicia Kleb’ (The Police are Dogs) has words and gestures that are unethical, abusive and threatening towards security forces and magistrates,” the ministry said.

“A police investigation identified those who made and released the video… there are eight of them. On Sunday, March 10, two of them, a young man and a girl, were arrested,” the ministry added.

The Ben Arous court in Tunis authorized their detention, the ministry said.

Media outlets reported that the two were a cameraman and an actress seen in the clip, adding that the rapper, Weld El 15, was being sought.

Interior ministry spokesman Riahi Adel said the two were arrested for slander and rebelling against officials, and that they could face up to five years in prison.

In the video Weld El 15 is heard saying “I will slit the throat of policemen like sheep,” and “give me a gun, I’ll shoot them.”


According to this report the law under which they are being prosecuted is for ” la calomnie et la rébellion contre les fonctionnaires”, slander and revolt against state employees”.

The Interior Ministry has justified its action by saying that the words of the songs,  « contient des expressions et des gestes contraires à la morale, injurieux et menaçants envers les agents de la sécurité et les magistrats ». They contain expressions and gestures contrary to morality, that are insulting and threatening towards the Police and Magistrates.” (Jeune Afrique).

Written by Andrew Coates

March 14, 2013 at 12:04 pm

Brigitte Bardot to move to Russia to follow Depardieu.

with 7 comments

Bardot to Quit France, a Nation Mourns.

On Europe I this morning and here,

“Famous French actress Brigitte Bardot threatened the French authorities, following her colleague Gerard Depardieu, that she would seek Russian citizenship. Bardot, being an active defender of animals, tries to attract public    attention to the euthanasia of sick elephants in a Lyon circus.”

More here.

Bardot is most famous for her perfect bum, in the film, Le Mépris, and her ability to sing in the same key, again and again,  for her- numerous – Records is an active supporter of the French far-right and animal rights.

Bon débarras!

Written by Andrew Coates

January 5, 2013 at 12:14 pm

Defend the BBC !

with 2 comments

“The BBC News Service is the worst in the world, except for all the others.”

Old Saying.

The BBC’s director of news, Helen Boaden, and her deputy Steve Mitchell have been asked to “step aside” pending the outcome of an internal review (Here).

The fall out from the Newsnight report which led to former Tory treasurer, Lord McAlpine, being wrongly accused of child abuse in north Wales in the 1980s continues.

This is of great importance. The BBC is under attack by the usual quarters. The aim of some of them is not just to discredit the Corporation to hide their own faults (Murdoch) but to pave the way for its break up and privatisation.

There is little to add to comments on the McAlpine scandal.

Except that Michael Crick pointed out in the Observer yesterday that Newsnight had not contacted the former Tory Treasurer to put the allegations to him.

This contrasts with the normal procedures of the programme.

They have an absolutely rock solid and deserved reputation for solid investigation.

For example, earlier this year a Newsnight producer contacted me about a programme they were doing on Work Experience. We spoke for nearly half an hour on the Work Programme in general. Some of my concerns were reflected in the broadcast.

Thousands of other people will have had the same experience.

But the present crisis is not just of the BBC’s own making.

It is being fuelled by the long-standing attitude of political figures towards the BBC.

  • Conservatives have long disliked the Corporation’s ‘liberal’ agenda.  The Tory Cabinet resents the BBC’s refusal to let their opinions define its centre of gravity rightwards. Hysterics like Peter Hitchens blame it for moral decline. There is more mainstream resentment. Ipswich Conservative MP Ben Gummer whined recently when the BBC put his plan to give business people an extra vote and say in local politics on-line.
  • Many on left are hostile to the BBC. Sometimes there is the sweeping claim that it represents ‘Wetsern values’. A more serious (and in my opinion, well-founded) objection is that it that it is biased against anything outside the ‘centre-left’. The coverage of Jean-Luc Mélenchon  during the French Presidential election,  was unremittingly hostile. Trade union action, above all strikes, are, as Le Monde has noted, considered in terms of “disruption”. The justice or otherwise of union demands is rarely considered.
  • Politicians of all sides always want to ‘correct’ reports about them and their parties. The Malcoms of this world will say that they respect the right of journalists to report and comment. They, however, just want the ‘facts’ (that is their views) to be given.

Political creatures are naturally news addicts.

Much of what’s cited above are ways of saying, “we want the news we agree with” (I include my own reactions).

Today you can see others news channels.

Not just the respected Channel Four but Sky, Russia Today and Al Jazeera, are available on digital free-view.

Sky is piss-poor and bland. Russia Today is made up of faux ‘anti-globalisation’ reports which are at the limit of any kind of objectivity.

Al Jazeera by contrast is serious. It carries investigations into subjects, such as the discrimination against Egyptian Copts, that confound criticisms of Islamic bias. But is  owned by the Qatari State, in which the unelected Emir holds supreme power.

For these reasons, for all Al Jazeera’s merits there are always bound to be controversies about its coverage. I have yet to see a documentary on the poor conditions for immigrant labour in Qatar.

The BBC faces no such objections.

This,  then, is my, unasked for, opinion.

If anybody fucking thinks that attacking the Corporation is going to be an easy touch know this: many many of us have great respect for the institution and will back its independence to the hilt.

Le lièvre de Patagonie: Claude Lanzman in the Observer.

leave a comment »


They have translated Claude Lanzman’s Le lièvre de Patagonie into English.

There was a fine article by Ed Vulliamy  based around an encounter with Lanzman.

But our enjoyment of this (belated) recognition was really spoilt by this:

Lanzmann fought in the French Resistance against the Nazis. As a reporter, he sent word to the west of conditions inside communist states. As a war correspondent, he faced artillery barrages in Algeria and tear gas on the Paris barricades. But the story that cost him most heart-searching and grief was that of his own family. His father’s sexual abuse of Lanzmann’s mother, and the suicide of his sister, seemed too awful to write about. Now he has broken his silence. That kind of courage, bearing witness in the face of personal pain, is a type we can all admire and aspire to.

My copy of the book has a publication date of 2009.

Of course that’s in French, which obviously doesn’t count.

It was first given a lengthy article in English language publications by the Times Literary Supplement which has a rather finer record of reviewing European literature than the Observer.

I find it immensely distasteful   that the Observer Editorialist chose to cite these allegations.

The first, focuses on the claim that Lanzman’s father attempted to have anal sex with his mother.

Judge of that what you will.

The second allegation is that Deleuze (the Leftist philosopher) was in some way, as a man conducting an affair with her, responsible for his Sister’s suicide.

To say that this is foul lie is the least of it.

Oh, and the book was reviewed on this Blog…a year ago.

That is the French original though there was a discussion of the Hebrew translation.

Which I think Ed Vulliamy would know since I don’t see anybody else making 25 hits on this (in the past two weeks) on this post on this site. 


Written by Andrew Coates

March 5, 2012 at 11:46 am

Posted in European Left, French Politics

Tagged with ,

Great Expectations on the BBC.

leave a comment »

A point apparently done to death deserves to be repeated.

Did we need another Great Expectations?

The answer is clearly no.

Not that it wasn’t a fine dramatisation.

I enjoyed it thoroughly.

Magwitch was particularly fine.

But why was it made?

Now we can look forward to seeing the seriously flawed, uncompleted, novel Edwin Drood.

Okay it’s the anniversary.

But that’s not excuse for the dearth of drama from other than a tiny set of writers from the Great Tradition.

Are there no other authors’ writings available?

And not always English ones?

Time was the BBC would think, I have heard, of dramatising Balzac.

Now there’s someone who can stand muster with Dickens any day.

Written by Andrew Coates

December 30, 2011 at 1:59 pm

Posted in Britain, Culture

Tagged with ,

Camus in the Panthéon ?

with 2 comments

Albert Camus in the Panthéon ?

Nicolas Sarkozy would like to transfer the ashes of Camus – on the  50th anniversary of his death (the 4th of  January 1960) to the Paris Pantheon. That is the national memorial for GRANDS HOMMES LA PATRIE RECONNAISSANTE (“To the great men, the grateful homeland”). Interment here is severely restricted and is allowed only by a parliamentary act for “National Heroes”.

His son Jean  is opposed (here).

There was an extraordinary brilliant and concise interview with Camus’ biographer, Olivier Todd, in le Monde yesterday (here). Todd, a first-hand witness of the post-War Left Bank, refers to Camus’s brief membership of the Algerican Communist party in 1934 – he left because it failed to support independence movements clearly enough. In the full article (the on-line version is cut), there is an account of the author of the Etranger’s later hesitation about the FLN’s campaign for full independence. And an account of  his disputes with Sartre – right about Stalinism, wrong about anti-colonialism.

Todd’s judgement on Camus is worth citing, ” Camus fut d’abord un écrivain, un artiste, un artisan, beaucoup plus qu’un philosophe dans la série Platon, Kant, Sartre, Wittgenstein.” He was first of all a writer, an artist, a workman, much more than a philosopher in the mould of Plato, Kant, Sartre, Wittgenstein.” This view TC shares.

His courageous Resistance  activity, his journalism,  moral presence on the left, and searing novels deserve better than a credential-boosting stunt by Sarkozy.  

Written by Andrew Coates

November 22, 2009 at 12:55 pm